Why Abdul Carter is the Top Candidate for 2025 NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year

New York, NY – May 22, 2025

Abdul Carter, selected No. 3 overall by the New York Giants in the 2025 NFL Draft, has emerged as the frontrunner for the 2025 Defensive Rookie of the Year (DROY) award. The former Penn State star’s blend of elite talent, favorable team situation, and the historical edge for edge rushers positions him as the standout candidate. Here’s why Carter is poised to claim the coveted honor.

Stellar College Performance

Carter dominated at Penn State, recording 12 sacks, 23.5 tackles for loss, and 66 pressures in 2024, earning a 92.4 PFF pass-rush grade and Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year honors. Transitioning from off-ball linebacker to full-time edge rusher, he showcased explosive speed (4.48-second 40-yard dash despite a foot injury) and versatile skills, excelling in pass rush, run defense, and occasional coverage. His NFL-ready technique and adaptability set him apart from competitors like Jalon Walker or Travis Hunter.

Ideal Fit with the Giants

Joining a Giants defense featuring Dexter Lawrence, Brian Burns, and Kayvon Thibodeaux, Carter benefits from a setup that creates one-on-one opportunities. Defensive coordinator Shane Bowen’s scheme maximizes edge rushers, and Carter’s burst and finesse make him a perfect fit. Analysts, including Shawne Merriman, predict 10+ sacks for Carter, a benchmark that could propel him to DROY glory in a stacked defensive unit that ranked top-10 in sacks (45) in 2024.

Historical Edge for Edge Rushers

The DROY award favors edge rushers, with five of the last six winners (Jared Verse, Will Anderson Jr., Micah Parsons, Chase Young, Nick Bosa) playing the position. Sacks and pressures resonate with voters, giving Carter an edge over cornerbacks like Will Johnson or safeties like Harold Emmanwori, who face tougher paths to standout stats. Unlike Travis Hunter, whose dual-role limits defensive snaps, Carter’s full-time pass-rush role ensures ample opportunities to shine.

Competitive Advantage

Compared to peers, Carter’s path is clearer. Jalon Walker (Falcons) shares snaps with veterans, while Mason Graham (Browns), a defensive tackle, struggles to match edge rusher statlines. Carter’s projected 10-12 sacks and central role in New York’s defense outshine these rivals. His resilience, evidenced by overcoming a foot injury, and bold mindset—calling himself the draft’s best player—fuel his drive.

Conclusion

Abdul Carter’s elite production, perfect fit with the Giants, and historical advantage as an edge rusher make him the top candidate for the 2025 DROY award. With the potential to redefine New York’s defense, Carter is set for a breakout rookie season that could cement his name among NFL greats.